Skip to the stories
Microsoft 365 & SharePoint

In-house legal teams say AI is adding work, not cutting it

Legal leaders at Eir, Uniphar, Wayflyer and others say AI is growing their workload, while token-metered pricing makes costs hard to forecast.

In-house legal teams say AI is adding work, not cutting it

Most of the AI debate in legal departments has been about headcount. A new report asks a different question: what happens to the work once the tools are in place? The answer, from interviews with legal and compliance leaders, is that the time AI frees up tends to get filled quickly, often with work the tools themselves helped create.

Two men and one woman smile to camera with screen behind.

'From AI Adoption to AI Advantage' was produced by Dentons Ireland and SiliconRepublic.com. It draws on interviews with leaders at Eir, Flipdish, Gilead Sciences, IMRO, Mastercard, Uniphar and Wayflyer. Rather than publishing another set of survey numbers, the authors wanted to see what responsible and effective use looks like inside a legal function right now. The picture that emerged often cut against the conventional wisdom.

Augmentation, not replacement

Almost none of the interviewees said AI had replaced a role or a function outright. Where it's paying off, the gains sit in repetitive work: invoice review, contract checking and customer screening. The research, drafting and judgement calls at the centre of the job have largely stayed with people.

Sergey Kinchin, senior counsel at Uniphar, said his view had shifted within a year. "Last year I would have thought it would probably reduce headcount. Now I'm seeing it more as unlocking unmet demand," he said. "I think the complexity of the work that's left after AI will increase. The bottom might shift up, but the overall pyramid of work will increase and grow."

Máire Neary, who was VP of people and legal at Flipdish when she was interviewed, framed AI as "a junior colleague, something that's additive, that can challenge me, but you have to remember you're the lawyer in charge at the end of the day." That's a useful framing for anyone writing an acceptable-use policy. The tool can draft and challenge, but accountability stays with the lawyer who signs.

EU AI Act – the high-risk classification guidelines explained

More to read, more to answer

Here's the catch: the same tools are now in the hands of everyone on the other side of the table. A long, polished complaint, subject access request or grievance costs almost nothing to produce. The report says AI-assisted drafting now seems to touch the majority of incoming disputes, subject access requests, grievances and customer complaints.

Sorcha Nic Mhurchú, general counsel at Eir, said the bottleneck is less about reading that material than sorting through it. "You end up going back and having to figure out, line by line, what is relevant," she said. "So that adds a lot of volume and time to any response, and that's a reality for everybody, not just us."

What do you need to know about the EU Pay Transparency Directive?

Seán Donegan, chief commercial officer at IMRO, said he'd seen the pattern coming. "Two years ago, I sat down with our licensing team and I said, guys, I'm going to make a prediction now," he said. "The volume and tenacity of queries and complaints is going to increase exponentially with these AI tools."

The problem isn't limited to inbound correspondence. Kinchin described a meeting with a part of the business that had gone all-in on AI. "We joined a call and we had five people bring six AI-generated opinions to the call, on a question that touched a regulatory issue," he said. "In trying to reconcile it, the AI had essentially confused itself."

What EU Inc really means for Europe’s start-ups – a legal view

Deirdre McCarthy, chief legal and people officer at Wayflyer, said quality is now as much of a concern as quantity. "AI can produce so much content that sometimes looks good, but may not always be good," she said. "So you can end up with people spending a lot of time just trading red lines because they're putting it into their AI tool."

Carlo Salizzo, head of technology and digital regulation at Dentons Ireland, drew the obvious conclusion when he spoke at a preview of the report on 22 October. "In a world increasingly full of AI-generated legal content, genuine human judgement may become more valuable rather than less," he said.

Almost half of Irish companies failing to address skills gap, finds Learnovate

The ROI question

Costs are easy to count. Returns are not. Neary was blunt about the risk of experimenting for its own sake. "I think we've seen a lot of AI for AI's sake, but every lawyer, every operator, needs to ask what the return on investment is," she said. "It's great if your team is enjoying building and experimenting and having fun, but what have you got to show for it, particularly once you're looking at a high LLM [large language model] bill, or the cost of maintaining it down the line?"

None of the interviewees felt confident they could show a return beyond the obvious gains in efficiency and risk reduction. Rebekah Dobson, head of international legal operations at Gilead Sciences, argued that the question itself is flawed. "No one has proved ROI on AI as of yet because companies were not tracking the metrics prior to AI to have a starting point for setting KPIs and measuring impact of AI," she said. She also pointed to a comparison she'd recently read: "you don't make Excel prove its ROI, it's just there."

Moving from organisational implementation to scaling of AI

David Kirton, partner in technology and digital regulation at Dentons Ireland, put the measurement gap in one line. "We tend to record the work lawyers do. We are much less good at recording the work they no longer have to do," he said. If you can't see the avoided work, you can't easily put a value on it. That's a practical problem for any legal ops team asked to justify a budget line.

Tokenomics

Cost has so far only moved in one direction. As AI providers shift from flat licence or per-seat fees to consumption-based, token-metered pricing, bills become much harder to forecast. For IT and procurement teams, this is the part that deserves early attention.

Rise of AI not deterring parents from backing their child’s STEM interests

Nic Mhurchú said Eir worries about being stuck on a treadmill. "The licence fees and the token fees are so huge that we fear that if we start adopting and using and buying licences, we're on a treadmill of just paying more fees, because these companies have to justify the high investment that they've been putting into these tools," she said.

Jessica Williams, vice-president of legal tech strategy at Mastercard, wants vendors to offer more controls. "Budgets aren't infinite and I'm going to have three or four people who are AI geniuses and they're going to burn through tokens," she said. "Then I'm going to have a bunch of other people who just do one or two things here and there... How do I balance all of that and create a predictable budget line for the company?"

Cornelius Grossmann, Dentons' global head of solutions development, expects AI costs to rise two- to fivefold within two years and warned of a coming "cost cliff." "I think the whole token economics will mean we'll probably hire people to monitor AI cost in a big law firm," he said. "And others may need to do that too, because it could bankrupt you if you don't pay attention."

McCarthy expects token spend to become the next big management question. "I think this is the next interesting wave, what we spend on AI and who gets to spend what, based on the tasks at hand?" she said. Kirton echoed the point with a list of questions many leaders are still working through: "Who gets access? Which tasks justify the cost? How do you allocate consumption across a business? And how do you prevent successful adoption from producing an unexpectedly large technology bill?" He added that many legal leaders are trying to manage that exposure without throttling the adoption they've worked hard to win.

Taken together, the interviews describe a renegotiation rather than a straightforward upgrade. Who does what, who is trained for what and who pays for what are all being settled in real time, while the technology keeps changing. Salizzo noted that the legal function hasn't been transformed by technology to the same extent as finance, sales or procurement. "AI may be the catalyst that changes that," he said.

My read is that the teams who come out ahead will be the ones that start measuring now, even imperfectly. Log the work that gets avoided, put token consumption under a named owner, and set access rules before the first large bill arrives. Those steps won't settle the ROI debate, but they'll give you something to show when someone asks what the money bought.

Source: Ann O’Dea · www.siliconrepublic.com

Same flag